Guilty Pleasure: Surface (Spoiler Warning)
When the fall season began, there were so many Lost-inspired or alien-themed shows that I made bets, solely based on the commercials, which show would be the most craptacular and derivative. Surface was at the top of my list as the first show to be cancelled, but I am embarrassed to admit that I am glad that I was wrong.
On the surface (I'm sorry, but I couldn't resist), it is a show about sea creatures possibly from another world or from the oceanic depths. These sea creatures may endanger the entire planet by devouring the ocean's food supply and then humanity. The story focuses on three people: Laura, a hot oceanographer single mom, Rich, a Southern every man and survivor of one attack, and Miles, an awkward teenager.
Surface is not ground-breaking. When I read the reviews for this show, each review alluded to Close Encounters of the Third Kind, which I have not seen yet. (I will be the first to admit that it is a cardinal sin not to see this film, particularly considering Julia Phillips role in it. If you don't know who she is, I suggest that you immediately purchase and read You'll Never Eat Lunch in This Town Again, a great tell-all memoir about life in Hollywood.)
Everyone is missing the point. Surface is derivative and comfortable so the viewer can get lulled into the story. The special effects are dated if the viewer focuses too long upon the images, but the emotion of the story energizes the plot by using the heart of the show, Miles. It is a sci-fi soap opera, and Surface gives the viewer a narrative spliced together with well-known and beloved plots to make one show.
The first few weeks were quite predictable. For example, Miles adopts one of the sea creatures, names him E.T., ahem Nim (short for Nimrod), then is forced to return his beloved pet to the ocean or else endanger Nim, who is being chased by local officials who simply think of Nim as a threat to others. I have to admit that I cried repeatedly when Miles parted from Nim, and Nim glows goodbye as he disappears into the waves. Miles lingers in the ocean and looks into the distance with a look of devastation.
If you have not lost a pet or loved an animal, then don't bother reading any further. I have had three cats and felt incredibly close to each of them. As my time with each of them ended for different reasons, I still torture myself with the thought that I was a bad owner and should have done anything to prevent that end.
Surface takes each of these normal feelings one step farther. Nim discovers that he has no home, and Miles takes unbelievable steps to protect Nim. While looking for him, Miles encounters Nim's more aggressive counterparts who attack and fatally wound him. Fortunately, Nim's goodbye was only a see ya later because soon the traumatized Nim is forced to return to Miles after being caught in a net and tortured by his captors. Before Miles can die in the hospital, Nim cures Miles and is killed. Miles wakes up devastated but changed. When Nim rises from the dead (of course) on the autopsy table in the aquarium, Miles discovers that he is changing and has a strange link to Nim. Um, E.T. never converted people.
Suddenly when I was least expecting it, the show has morphed into a pastiche of a number of werewolf stories and the X-Men. A recent episode ended with Miles solemnly leading a number of aggressive sea creatures, including Nim, into the ocean away from the violent encounter with townspeople in Wilmington, North Carolina. Before his intervention, the people were ready to kill the creatures, until they discovered that they couldn't and were attacked with Nim in the lead.
Tonight's episode brought the allusion to the X-Men to the forefront by Miles being threatened by the townspeople as a "mutant." It is no accident that the show takes place in the South because Miles and his family are nearly lynched before he is rescued by a tsunami warning. Deep Impact anyone? The tsunami may have been caused by the sea creatures disturbing the earth's plate tectonics. (I'm just grateful that the end of the world begins in a bucolic Southern sea coast town instead of a major metropolitan area such as New York City or Los Angeles.)
Meanwhile when the story gets too touchy-feely, the oceanographer and good ol' Southern boy are caught up in a conspiracy corporate cover-up, which may or may not involve the government. Apparently a corporation has created these creatures, along with a number of others, for reasons unknown and Rich practically exclaims that it is an abomination. Frankenstein? I'm sure that I missed a number of allusions.
Surface is a comfortable show that rewards the viewer weekly by offering archetypical plots in order to make us feel like the show is progressing. It is as exploitive as hell, but it sure is a fun ride. Any show that ends the world is a winner in my book.
